Thursday, July 22, 2010

Review: Love in the Afternoon (Hathaways, Book 5) by Lisa Kleypas

I didn't mean to send love letters, but that is
what they became. On their way to you, my
words turned into heartbeats on the page.

Come back, please come home and find me.


Ahhh Beatrix, I loved this character and was intrigued by her for quite a while. From all the Hathaway sisters, she's the one who really made me curious. The girl who loves animals and can't seem to really adjust to society's rules and regulations -- uncivilized, direct and honest Beatrix. Who in that society could ever love her, right?

I'm so glad that in the end, Lisa Kleypas found the right touch and wrote a great romance for Beatrix. Kleypas begins Love in the Afternoon with a love letter and sets the tone for Beatrix Hathaway and Christopher Phelan' romance.

So there we are, Beatrix and Christopher's fall in love through letters. Lovely letters. They are letters full of honesty and deception, at least on Beatrix's side. Honest Beatrix begins writing to Christopher as act of kindness after her shallow friend Prudence Mercer refuses to answer a letter she receives from him -- a letter he writes from the front as he is fighting abroad for England.

However, Beatrix deceives Christopher by pretending to be Pru throughout their correspondence. She believes that he would not appreciate receiving a letter from her. Beatrix's memory of Christopher is that of a shallow, blond god with not much to offer but his good looks. He publicly made some hurtful remarks and judged Beatrix for her unconventional actions, comments she herself overheard. But the war and that one letter to Prudence touched her. What was written in that letter didn't reflect the man Beatrix thought Christopher to be, and what began as a small deception and an act of kindness turned into love and agony for Beatrix, and love, hope and despair for Christopher. See, Christopher falls in love with the woman on the page, words... words matter in this story.

I love this romance. It is not all wine and flowers and wounded animals, although there are plenty of those to be found, but it is about love and healing. Christopher falls desperately in love with the woman revealed through the letters believing she is Pru. When he returns, he slowly realizes that woman is not Pru, instead he finds unconventional Beatrix. There's passion between them... and I loved both the passion and restraint between these two, the sexual tension and the desperate love that oozes from both Christopher and Beatrix. Especially throughout the first three quarters of the book.

Christopher is not the same man who left England. He returns from the wars a changed man suffering from PTSD. He believes he's going mad and you can feel his conflict, desperation and anguish. So as I said this is not a story that is all love and flowers, there are other conflicts that present themselves along the way. I like the compromises Kleypas uses as a partial resolution to this storyline.

As secondary characters, the Hathaways make appearances and as this is the end of the series, there are resolutions to some minor issues. I again loved Leo in this installment, both his often-inappropriate sense of humor and moments of insight. There's a secondary story about a friend of Christopher's that is also part of the conflict that is satisfactorily, if easily, resolved.

I loved Love in the Afternoon. I think Beatrix and Christopher's lovely and passionate romance was an excellent way to end the Hathaway series. Beatrix was special and Christopher was the perfect hero for her -- all wounded and so in love. Married by Morning was a treat for me, but I must admit that I preferred the romance in this book just a bit more. I'll miss looking forward to new Hathaway stories, but will enjoy their journeys again through re-reads.

Genre: Historical Romance
Series: Hathaway Series, Book 5
Release Date: June 29, 2010 - Kindle Edition
Grade: A-

Visit Lisa Kleypas here

KMont's 2010 Year of the Historical Challenge


  1. This was a great romance and I loved Beatrix and Christopher together. Just good stuff.

  2. Everyone seems to love this one. Can't wait to read it!

  3. Great review Hilcia! I've been avoiding the "European Historical" like the plague lately but this book sounds lovely. I looks like I'm going to be adding 5 more books to my wishlist.

  4. Tracy, it really was good stuff! LOL! Loved this romance. *sigh*

    Leslie I can see why everyone likes seems to like it. I know I did. Funny I thought Married by Morning was going to be my favorite in this series, and yet this was it!

    Novelnelle, thanks! I think Kleypas and Balogh are two exceptions ATM -- I've mainly be reading historical romance americana. This was a good series by Kleypas, this book is my favorite.

  5. I love the letters between Beatrix and Christopher. I loved how they came together...however, I wished Christopher had apologized for the hurtful words he said about Beatrix. It seems the changed man excused the man he was before, how he was towards Beatrix before he got to know her. But that's just a small quibble. Good book and a great ending to the series!

  6. Yes, they were great! That didn't bother me at all Tabz. I think both Christopher & Beatrix apologized enough in this story, certainly for the important things, he for being rude, etc... and she for deceiving him. He certainly recognized the importance of words and how they can hurt and make a difference.

    When this particular incident came up between them, I liked how simply Keyplas handled it. Beatrix tells him "You thought I was peculiar." They're hugging at the time, she feels his smile against her neck and he says "Darling love... you are." And hmm... she is and that's okay. *g*

  7. Hils, did you feel, then that the book was pretty engaging the whole way through? I mean, I'm guessing yes since we've got this great grade here, but the thing that gave me the most pause on Dear Author's review is that DA Jane thought the book's tension kind of fizzled, leaving about half the book not as exciting. Did you find this to be so, from your perspective?

  8. KMont, from my perspective this story was excellent as a romance. There's romance, and then sexual tension during the first part of the book. The romance continues, there's still some sexual tension, plus you'll find sexual scenes during the last part of the book. So I thought Keyplas did a good job in balancing out the story in that respect. Also, the conflict between the H/H continue... and those are not resolved until the end of the story.

    I had a few niggles, which is why is not a straight A, but overall yes... I really enjoyed it. :D

  9. Awesome, Hils, thanks. ;) I'm torn now whether to give the Kleypas before this one a go next or that Loretta Chase title I've got.

  10. LOL! If you're talking about Don't Tempt Me... then you have a tough choice. I really enjoyed that book too! I think I gave it a B+... I reaaally had fun reading and reviewing that book! Loved Zoe Octavia.
    - Show quoted text -

  11. I've only read the first two books in the series to date - I'm so in love with Cam (he's swoon worthy IMHO :) Not sure how keen I am on the fourth book, but I like the sound of the fifth. Do you think I can skip the fourth?

  12. Orannia, I agree about Cam. [swoon]

    I don't why not! I'm sure you can skip the 4th book and go on to this one... they're all self-contained romances. :)

  13. Great review Hils :D You know how I feel about this book and I agree with you all the way LOL.

    I think the family was great in this one :D and they never detract from Beatrix and Christopher :P

  14. Yay! The Hathays as a whole were great in this book. Not too much, but there so we were able to enjoy them. Nice. :D


Anonymous Users disallowed due to large influx of spam.

Note: Only a member of this blog may post a comment.