Tuesday, February 9, 2010
Review: The Outback Stars by Sandra McDonald
In The Outback Stars, McDonald introduces Team Space, a military organization in charge of inter-planetary space travel. Team Space travels through alien-built space passageways called the "Alcheringa." The route allows space ships to travel between worlds -- think wormholes.
McDonald's world is based on native Australian mythology. Everything from planets, objects, to the alien race have Australian names and are based on tribal Australian culture. I'm not familiar with this mythology or culture and cannot attest as to its authenticity in this book or lack thereof. I can tell you that her world is definitely an interesting one.
Lieutenant Jodenny Scott is our principal character in what turned out to be a large ensemble of characters. Jodenny is still recovering from the traumatic loss of her last ship, the Yangtze -- a disaster being blamed on colonial separatist terrorists. Although physically recovered, and despite her heroic actions during the tragedy, Jodenny still suffers from both the trauma of having seen her loved ones die and survivor's guilt.
Jodenny procures a berth on the Aral Sea where she's placed in charge of Underway Stores or supplies. She finds a dysfunctional ship and a troubled department full of inadequate, unprofessional and inefficient staff. There are problems with thefts, rape accusations, beatings, fights, accidents, gangs, missing inventory and everyone seems to have a secret. Jodenny is expected to straighten it all out. On top of that, she also has to deal with shipboard politics -- intrigue abounds.
This is where I think McDonald excels. She weaves the shipboard politics and the nitty gritty detail about military life on a ship beautifully. She takes her time outlining protocol and other details that would otherwise seem unimportant and makes them part of the plot. The author herself was in the military and this is made obvious by how well these details are incorporated into the book.
However, the whole story doesn't take place on the ship. While on leave at Mary River, Jodenny and Sargeant Terry Myell stumble on a discovery that could change the way everything works in their world. The plot thickens as Jodenny and Terry are catapulted into an intriguing, dangerous and often mystifying situation. In the process, they fall in love creating a career-ending situation for themselves, as their relationship is forbidden by military rules.
I thought The Outback Stars was quite the ambitious undertaking and wasn't too sure about it for a while. McDonald introduces the reader to her worldbuilding quite slowly, but certain aspects of it kept my attention and I got into it. Her world was interesting, it bordered on fantasy and that part was a surprise. Although creative, I wasn't entirely satisfied with McDonald's worldbuilding. Too often I felt as though I were left in the dark for far too long about certain details, and that made for a frustrating read. Also by the end, there were either unanswered questions that should be answered in the next book, or confusing answers -- few conflicts seemed resolved or clear.
What I really enjoyed was McDonald's attention to detail when it came to the military side of the book and the humanity of her characters. She doesn't portray the secondary or central characters as super-heroes. Instead, they display the joys, fears, pride and jealousies you might expect of everyday people. That was a nice touch.
As you can see The Outback Stars was a mixed bag for me. I enjoyed the characters and am thinking of getting the next book in this series, The Stars Down Under, to see where Sandra McDonald takes them. Grade B-
The Outback Stars
The Stars Down Under
The Stars Blue Yonder
Visit Sandra McDonald here.
Subscribe to: Post Comments (Atom)
I've got this in the TBR pile and am really looking forward to it. Thanks to your review, I now know it's not quite the fluffy tale some on Amazon reviews have made it out to be. Several I read over there really seemed to disparage the book for having some romance in it. I should've realized that was the usual, stereotypical outlook talking. From your review, I et an entirely different impression and I like it.ReplyDelete
Interesting review Hils. I like the Australian aspect but not sure this is one for me.ReplyDelete
KMont, I know what you mean about those reviews. There is a romance, but it's definitely NOT the main focus of the story, or even a big part of it. Both characters are important to the storyline, but not necessarily as a couple. What I found was a mixture of military sci-fi, heavy on fantasy and a touch of romance. Hope to read your thoughts on this one. :)ReplyDelete
Leslie, the Australian mythology was definitely interesting as a basis for her worldbuilding. I found it fascinating. It looks as if she'll be expanding on it on the second book. However, if you don't enjoy the nitty gritty details in sci-fi, this book might not be for you. :)
I've never heard of this author or series... is it because the author is Australian?ReplyDelete
Hmmm, sounds like the book is very heavy. Are you planning to read the other books?
Nath, the author is American -- this was her first book and this is her first series. I heard about her while looking for some Sci-Fi/Romance and her name popped up. I'm not sure how popular her work is/or is not.ReplyDelete
I'm thinking of getting the second book. I had questions at the end of this book and would like to see if they're answered there. I enjoyed the characters & her style enough to give it a try. :)
This sounds like the type of book that I *think* I would love, but probably not take to when I actually sit down to read it. Military details usually bore me. Just ask my husband, I tune him out whenever he starts up about work life. :pReplyDelete
I'll definitely keep it on my radar though.
You might have a tough time getting through the first part of the book. The fantasy part takes over through the second part of the book... I'm wondering if the second book is more fantasy based. If I read it, I'll let you know. :)
I'm glad you enjoyed it Hils!ReplyDelete
She weaves the shipboard politics and the nitty gritty detail about military life on a ship beautifully.
*nods* I think that is why I enjoyed the first book more than the second (and yes, the second is more fantasy based) - I like shipboard politics. Actually, if you of any books like that, please can you let me know?
Orannia, the shipboard politics and the military based detail are what made this book enjoyable for me too. The fantasy part of it was all right, but not my favorite part of the book -- thanks for letting me know that takes over the series. :)ReplyDelete
I have Games of Command by Linnea Sinclair on my pile. I understand it's done in a similar style... but then I LOVE Sinclair. I haven't read it yet, but I'll be getting to it soon... I hope. :)