Saturday, December 11, 2010

Review: A Bride in the Bargain by Deeanne Gist

Hi everyone! Sorry I disappeared for a few days. I'm afraid that on top of starting a new job and all the changes to my schedule, I had a bit of an unexpected emergency in my family and my blogging and reading time was reduced dramatically this week. All should be going back to normal by Monday, and I expect that I'll be around again by next week. :)

Since I can't go without reading something, I looked through my Kindle and found a book that I read last year when it released and remember enjoying quite a bit - A Bride in the Bargain by Deeanne Gist - and decided to re-read it, slowly as the opportunity arose. I didn't write a review for this book the first time I read it, although I did include a few quick impressions with my Weekly Reads post at Musings.

Because my time is so restricted at the moment and I'm not sure how things are going to work out, this review will serve as an early posting for both my 2010 Re-Read Challenge and my 2010 Year of the Historical Challenge for the month of December.

In 1860s Seattle, a man with a wife could secure himself 640 acres of timberland. But because of his wife's untimely death, Joe Denton finds himself about to lose half of his claim. Still in mourning, his best solution is to buy one of those Mercer girls arriving from the East. A woman he'll marry in name but keep around mostly as a cook.

Anna Ivey's journey west with Asa Mercer's girls is an escape from the griefs of her past. She's not supposed to be a bride, though, just a cook for the girls. But when they land, she's handed to Joe Denton and the two find themselves in a knotty situation. She refuses to wed him and he's about to lose his land. With only a few months left, can Joe convince this provoking--but beguiling--easterner to be his bride?
A Bride in the Bargain by Deeanne Gist is an inspirational historical romance set in the Washington Territory during the Civil War. I don't usually read inspirational books, this was a first and still the only book in the sub-genre I've read. However, this book initially caught my attention because of the setting and the plot, and both turned out to be excellent.

I love Seattle, Washington. It's one of my favorite places and this story is set during the 1860's and highlights that area's history as Ms. Gist uses historical facts to weave this romance. In fact, quite a few of the characters in the book are based on personages who existed during those times and all the newspaper clippings featured in the book are taken from archives.

The story itself is based on truth and one shared by many men and women. Joe Denton needs a bride to keep his land. Ana Ivey is a nineteen year-old orphan from Granby, Massachusetts who lost her whole family during the Civil War. Destitute and desperate, she becomes one of the Mercer girls along with 299 other war widows or orphans. These women go west to marry or work after signing contracts with Mr. Mercer. On the other side of the country, the men also sign contracts and pay for brides or employees. In this case, Joe thinks he paid $300.00 for a bride. Ana thinks she paid $50.00 to work as a cook to Joe and his crew of lumberjacks. They are both deceived by Mr. Mercer.

This story shines when it comes to historical details and the beauty with which Ms. Gist describes the setting and circumstances. The romance itself is warm and there are many conflicts placed in the couple's path to resolve before the "happily ever after" is finally reached.  Joe and Ana are a nice couple and I really enjoyed most of their interactions and the way they slowly fall in love. Joe is portrayed as a good man who loves his land above all else. The land is satisfying enough, but he's lonely and obviously needs Ana in his life. Ana is a young woman, 19 years old, who after losing her whole family during the Civil War, is full of guilt and regret. She is what I think of as a plucky girl who won't back down, but has growing up to do.

As I mentioned above this is my one and only inspirational read. I was pleasantly surprised in that A Bride in the Bargain wasn't overly preachy throughout, instead the "inspirational" side of the story was more of a subtle message. The story wasn't perfect, however, and there were a few frustrating moments for me.

The first time I read the book, I grew a bit impatient towards the last quarter of the book with Ana's character and her lack of maturity. This time around, that section didn't seem to bother me as much as it did the first time -- Ana's circumstances were quite dire and the guilt and regret she felt, made her actions understandable.  However towards the end, there just seemed to be one too many dramatic obstacles thrown in the couple's path to deliver the message, and that did seem contrived and unnecessary. In my opinion by that time, the readers (and characters) had already received it.

Overall, A Bride in the Bargain is a book I would recommend to all romance readers as an great historical romance read - especially for those readers who love Americana and excellent historical details with their romance. This is a beautifully written book and if you're a reader who loves inspirational books, you will definitely love this book. I liked it the first time I read it, but I found that this story was more enjoyable for me the second time around.

Category: Historical Romance/Inspirational
Series: None
Released: June 1, 2009
Grade: B+

Visit Deeanne Gist here.

Nath's 2010 Re-Read Challenge - December Review
KMont's 2010 Year of Historical Challenge - December Review


  1. Hope everything is okay and life settles down for you. :)

    Wonderful review Hils - I have this one and a couple other Gist books on the tbr pile because of Wendy's reviews. And I love the Pacific NW setting.

  2. Hi JS.
    It's Sonia from the Phade. Hope you don't mind me just coming in here like this ^-^

    Thanks for this review, can you believe the coincidence, I also have one book by this author, also the first in the genre I'll try.
    Your review is a good omen lol, as I hope to enjoy my book as much as you've enjoyed yours. The one I have is A Bride most Begrudging and I'm hoping to read it this month, let's see...

    BTW, once again, great blog and colors fit well it's seems cozy ;)

  3. Hey Hils, hope everything is good at home :)

    Great review for this book. I have to admit though, I'm not sure if it's for me, not such a fan of Americana genre.

    Deeanne Gist, she's the same author that now has a fantasy series out, right? :)

  4. Things are better, Leslie. Thank you. :)

    If you love Pacific NW historical setting, then you'll really like this book. I really enjoy that aspect of this book. :) I'm also planning on reading other books by Gist.

    Sonia hello! I'm so glad you stopped by... love having you here. I'm glad you like the blog, colors, etc... :D

    Ohhh, you're going to read A Bride Most Begrudging! I can't to read your thoughts on that book. I'm hoping to read in the near future also. It's an interesting genre and I'm glad I gave it a try. Hugs!

    Nath, things are finally settling down and all is well. Thank you!

    I'm not sure if this is the same author Nath. I've only seen inspirational books by this author. I'll need to check that out. :)


Anonymous Users disallowed due to large influx of spam.

Note: Only a member of this blog may post a comment.