Thursday, November 29, 2012

Review: A Christmas Bride by Mary Balogh

A Christmas Bride
It has become tradition for me to kick off the Holidays by picking up one of Mary Balogh's many Christmas novellas. This year two of her old classics have been re-released in one book, just in time for the season. A Christmas Bride/Christmas Beau have been on my list for a while, now I own both. Here is my review for  A Christmas Bride.

The son of a Bristol merchant, Edgar Downes is an attorney and a  wealthy, successful merchant and businessman, a cit. His father believes that there's no better man or gentleman than his son and that Edgar deserves nothing less than a lady for a wife, so it is that at the age of thirty-six Edgar finds himself promising not only to search for a lady willing to marry him, but to bring her home as a Christmas bride. Luckily for Edgar, his sister Cora and brother-in-law Lord Francis Kneller invite him to London for the season, and along with their aristocratic friends plans are made to introduce him to eligible ladies. Aristocratic young ladies with parents willing to marry their daughters to a merchant are found, unfortunately during that first planned event the woman who catches Edgar's eye is the beautiful seductive widow wearing red, Lady Stapleton.

Helena is also shocked when the handsome, powerful and rather imposing stranger catches her eye and soon she maneuvers the situation until he escorts her home, alone, where she promptly seduces him. Almost immediately she regrets her weakness, and soon we are treated to the mocking, self-destructive, sarcastic, and hurtful Helena. Edgar is not much better, he is taken aback by Helena's passionate nature and his own passionate reaction to her. They both know they made a mistake, but soon find that there are consequences to that night of seduction that will change lives and take decisions out of their hands. As Christmas approaches and all make their way to Edgar's country estate, will those changes bring happiness? If it's up to Helena, the answer to that question is no.

Edgar Downes and Helene, Lady Stapleton were introduced in previous novels released by Balogh. Edgar is Fanny's (The Famous Heroine) older brother, and Helene is Gerald Stapleton's (A Precious Jewel) wicked step-mother. Yes, Helene is the villainess in that romance and for much of this romance Helena plays the role of the hurtful, mocking woman who embraces suffering for her past mistakes but takes that self-hatred out on those who attempt to make her happy, in this case Edgar. Helena's hard edges are in full display as she refuses to show a softer, vulnerable side or to embrace happiness because to her way of thinking she doesn't deserve it. And well, there's a good reason for that!

This situation with Helena might have been a total disaster if she had not warned Edgar from the beginning that she did not want happiness or him. She is straight forward and relentless when it comes to fighting deep feelings. He knows this, yet can't stop thinking that they are made for each other because she's a strong woman and he's willing to fight for a future. The man has the patience of Job! Actually Edgar is a man who knows how to control his domineering side quite well... and has no problem showing his softer side. He's a lovely man. Balogh works this rather prickly and rough relationship slowly from beginning to end. It works because although feelings change between the characters, the characters don't really change who they are, instead what is beneath the surface is revealed as the story moves along.

Edgar and Helena are excellent examples of Balogh protagonists with a bit of a twist. She is a woman willing to sacrifice happiness and he is an honorable man of character. I see two differences here from the norm: Helena's sacrifice doesn't come about because she's trying to protect someone else, and she's willing to hurt other people's feelings in order to punish herself. Balogh's usual heroine hurts herself before hurting others and sacrifices her own happiness for the sake of others. I actually found Helena as an ex-villainess who is not exactly looking for redemption, but finds it and doesn't necessarily change into an unrecognizable character, a bit of a refreshing protagonist -- particularly in a Christmas novella. This view of Helena, however, might not be shared by all readers.

Another aspect about this novella also surprising to me is that first seduction scene between Edgar and Helena. That has to be one of the most passionate bedroom scenes I've read so far in a Balogh novel or novella. Balogh's intimate scenes are known to be rather tame, and although in comparison to others out there it won't be considered over the top, in Balogh-land that is definitely a steamy scene!

As a Christmas novella set in the Regency era and written by Mary Balogh, you will find that no matter how non-traditional the trope or the characters in A Christmas Bride might be, her trademark traditional English Christmas scenes in the country are also very much a part of the story. Gorgeous secondary characters with interesting little stories of their own abound, but in this novella the most interesting  aspect of those secondary characters is that most of them come from other romances -- besides the ones mentioned above the group also involves the Duke and Duchess of Bridgwater (The Plumed Bonnet), Jennifer and Gabe (Dark Angel), and Hartley and Samantha (Lord Carew's Bride). It's a happy reunion full of family and friends with the focus always kept firmly on the romance.

I really enjoyed A Christmas Bride with its non-traditional heroine and traditional Christmas story about forgiveness and redemption -- and boy, nobody needed forgiveness and redemption more than Helena! It gave me that kick start I needed to get me into the mood to read all those holiday books I have sitting on my coffee table. Reading now, Christmas Beau.        

Category: Historical Romance/Holiday
Series: None
Publisher/Release Date: Dell/November 27, 2012
Grade: B+

Visit Mary Balogh here.


  1. You've already read and reviewed The Christmas Bride, Hils?!? Really!?! I just reminded you it came out on Tuesday! How do you do it? LOL.

    Yeah, the fact that Helena is the wicked stepmother is what is giving me pause about this book. Not that I've read Gerard book, LOL... So I guess I really don't have any reason not to read this ^_^;

    It sounds a bit different than Ms Balogh's usual book... Anyway, glad you enjoyed it! Hopefully, I'll read and review it as part of my Christmas books :)

    1. Nath, I told you I was ready for this one! It was time for a Christmas read, and a review of a Christmas book. lol! Plus, I'm trying to get back on my reviewing roll. *g*

      Ahh, the wicked, hardened step-mother/woman as a heroine bit. I think it made for a good/different sort of Christmas read. If you haven't read A Precious Jewel yet, then it might not have as much of an impact on you... read that book afterward! That's a plan! I read it a while back, but never reviewed it (I was too caught up in A Matter of Class at the time).

      Keep it in mind. :D

  2. I just love this author!!! I haven't read any of her christmas stories this one is definitely going on my TBR list!!! Thanks for the lovely review!!!

    1. LoR, Balogh is great isn't she? Her Christmas stories are the best (says a huge fan), and I recommend them to you, particularly if you like her style. So yes, I recommend this one and all her Christmas stories. :)

  3. I remember I went through a Balogh kick a few years ago and I read this one, and yeah, it was rather different from others, but in the end I really like it too. She's a great author.

    1. Alex, are you feeling better? I'm glad you're back!

      This IS a bit different, right? I think I liked most because of that... and because Balogh made it work. And yeah... I do enjoy her work.

  4. I am scouring the library website, just WAITING for this one to come in.. but honestly.. after just typing that I think I should go buy it. I have a thing for Christmas romances and even have a little collection. I think I will! Thanks for the review, Hils. I can't wait to read this one and get in the mood. :)

    1. Christine, I collect Balogh's work in print, and these re-releases of her old works (Signets) I think are worth collecting since originals are so hard to find. :) This is a good one to buy... both stories are different from the "usual" Balogh.


Anonymous Users disallowed due to large influx of spam.

Note: Only a member of this blog may post a comment.