Friday, July 13, 2012

Review: It Takes Two by Elliott Mackle

It Takes Two is a gay historical romance/mystery set right after World War II in the Southern town of Fort Myers, Florida. In his first novel, Elliott Mackle tackles bigotry against homosexuality and people of color, PTSD affecting veterans of World War II, and a 'why-done-it,' all while building a romance-in-the-making between the two central characters, Dan and Bud.

U.S. Navy veteran, Lieutenant Dan Ewing has suffered from survivors’ guilt and nightmares ever since he lost his best buddy and sexual partner of 18 months when his ship was sunk by a submarine and the majority of the men were lost at sea. In Spencer 'Bud' Wright, he finally seems to have found the man whose company helps him find solace. Unfortunately, Bud fights the reality of their attraction and relationship. Sergeant Bud Wright, veteran and ex-sharpshooter, is now a Lee County detective. He and Dan are having what he thinks of as a friendship with occasional sexual benefits. Bud is not beneath playing a little grab-ass, but a homosexual? No. He is confused and scared of the consequences, but most of all afraid 'mixing it up' with Dan might be more than just the fulfillment of a teen-age fantasy. What poor deluded Bud doesn't understand is that sooner or later Dan always gets what he wants.

Managing the Caloosa Hotel with its private club where gambling, drinking and loose behaviors are only acceptable behind closed doors becomes a dangerous proposition for Dan, especially after he inadvertently becomes involved in one of Bud's murder investigations. In a hotel room located at the edge of 'Colored Town,' two men are found shot: a colored soldier and a white man. The white man is husband to the daughter of the most influential man in town. All hell breaks loose when the white man's widow shows up and shoots up the scene, almost shooting Dan in the process. Bud and Dan get mixed up in a whydunit that involves powerful players, bigotry, the KKK, civil rights advocates, and corruption.

It Takes Two is written in the first person narrative from Dan's perspective. In Mackle's hands the first person point of view becomes quite effective as he creates a quick, intimate connection between the reader and the narrator's emotions. The result is that he reeled me in from page one. However, (and this has become one of my favorite aspects of Elliott Mackle's writing style), Bud and the secondary characters, as seen through Dan's point of view, are just as fleshed out as Dan is himself.

The story must be read and the characters viewed from a historical and not a contemporary perspective. These characters have just been through war, seen the world and experienced situations that vastly changed their lives and their points of view. Yet, with few exceptions, when they return home America remains much the same as before these soldiers went to war, particularly in places like Fort Myers. The time is right after World War II and Mackle certainly succeeds by using the right historical touches and creating an atmosphere that transports the reader to place and time. Personally, I love the way language is consistently used throughout to maximize all of the above.

Mr. Mackle utilizes the whydunit aspect of the story as a tool to enhance the historical elements, Southern atmosphere, and to develop the budding romance between Dan and Bud. Mackle also weaves in the subject of PTSD seamlessly and with authority, and by using ex-servicemen and women as central and secondary characters gives this story a wonderful military-on-leave atmosphere outside of the military environment that feels true to time and place, making It Takes Two an excellent read.

Last year, I fell a little in love with Elliott Mackle's writing style after reading Captain Harding's Six Day War because of the way he drew me into the story, but along the way found myself falling rather hard for his characters. Fortunately for me It Takes Two was reprinted and re-released because this time I fell rather hard for both his writing style as well as with his wonderful characters -- I loved Dan and Bud! This is a book I will re-read, so it is definitely highly recommended.

Category: LGBT - Gay Historical/Romance
Series: None
Publisher/Release Date: Lethe Press/June 1, 2012
Source: ARC from author
Grade: A

Visit Elliott Mackle here.


  1. Hilcia, Thanks so much for your generous review. You indeed get what I was trying to put across in the novel and you hand-sell it to your readers without spoilers. Two additional points, if I may. The sequel, "Only Make Believe," is in production and should appear next month, so these will technically become parts of a series. Also, my Authors Guild website is more up to date and I will be posting a link to your review there. It is

    1. Thank you for stopping by, Mr. Mackle. It was a pleasure reading It Takes Two (and Captain Harding's Six Day War). I obviously loved this book, so I now look forward to reading the sequel. That's great news!

      PS: I have updated my link to your website. Thank you.

  2. Hear hear - his writing style is amazingly engaging, - i mean i adore his Captain Harding books, and who would think that I'd ever like military stories?

  3. Cheers, Erastes. I agree. I can't seem to just read the first page of one of Mr. Mackle's books to test it out without getting caught up in the story.

    I love military stories and these books (the Captain Harding series included) are extremely enjoyable. :)

  4. Hils, May I ask a favor. Is there any way to get a permalink to the review? When I either post the link up top or use your share button what appears on the screen, say on FB, is my note to you, not the review. I admit I am not a programmer. Thanks.

    1. Hi Elliott,

      You are doing right! When you share to FB the title of the review becomes the link to the review. The first comment (in this case your comment) shows underneath. However, when your friends click on the title they'll come directly back here and can read the review. :) It should work!

      However, the direct link to the review should you need it for your website is:

      I hope that helps!


    2. Thanks. I can also link from your post on amazon so thanks muchly for that.


Anonymous Users disallowed due to large influx of spam.

Note: Only a member of this blog may post a comment.